Preservation groups join forces in lawsuit aimed at saving Rock Island County Courthouse

ROCK ISLAND, Illinois -- A handful of preservation groups have joined together to save the Rock Island County Courthouse by filing a lawsuit.

The lawsuit names the Rock Island County Public Building Commission (PBC) and the Rock Island County Board.

Click here to see the lawsuit. 

The courthouse has been a point of contention for years, with groups of people fighting to keep it as others, including Rock Island County Chief Judge Walter Braud, push to raze it.

The lawsuit claims the PBC and the county board are moving forward with the demolition in an illegal way, not complying with the Illinois State Historic Resources Preservation Act and violating the Illinois Public Building Commission Act.

Related: City of Rock Island won’t grant permit to demolish historic county courthouse without state approval

"Additionally, the lawsuit takes issue with the PBC's intention to use bonds that were issued exclusively for the Justice Center Annex to be illegally reallocated for the courthouse demolition," said a statement from Kaitlyn McAvoy, the communications manager with Landmarks Illinois.  Landmarks Illinois is a historic preservation advocacy nonprofit that's listed as a plaintiff in the lawsuit.

Judge Braud filed a court order in late January 2019 that ordered the immediate demolition of the courthouse.  The order stated that the building's condition posed "a real and present danger to the 1,000 persons per week that enter the newly constructed Annex," which is right next door to the courthouse.   He also cited that there was "no just cause or legal reasons" to delay the demolition.

Click here to see the full court order.

The courthouse has been around since 1896, and according to Landmarks Illinois, is eligible for a spot on the National Register of Historic Places.

The lawsuit is seeking a compromise with the PBC and county board.  McAvoy said Landmarks Illinois would like to see them work with area preservation agencies to "find a reuse for the historic courthouse building."  Their argument states that finding a new purpose for the courthouse would take away demolition costs, create new jobs and put the building on the tax roll.

Landmarks Illinois joined the following groups in the lawsuit: National Trust for Historic Preservation, Rock Island Preservation Society, Moline Preservation Society, Broadway Historic District Association and Fred Shaw, a Rock Island Justice Center bondholder.

Landmarks Illinois held a conference on the lawsuit. Click here to watch.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.