Follow the Good Morning Quad Cities 2018 Road Trip here

Man mistakenly released from prison 90 years too early

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

A Colorado man was mistakenly released from prison 90 years too early, and now has to go back to serve his full sentence after completely turning his life around.

ABC News reported that in 2000, Rene Lima-Marin and another man were convicted of multiple robbery, kidnapping, and burglary charges from an incident where the two had forced video store employees into a back room at gunpoint and demanded money from a safe.

Lima-Marin was ordered to serve eight back-to-back sentences equaling 98 years, but due to a court clerk error, the Department of Corrections thought the eight sentences were supposed to run at the same time for 16 years.

After serving eight years, Lima-Marin was mistakenly released on parole in 2008, according to the report.

Once released, ABC News reported that Lima-Marin learned to cut and install windows and started selling coupon books door-to-door. He married a former girlfriend, Jasmine, and helped raise her son. The two also gave birth to another son.

A former prosecutor who was checking on the status of Rene’s case found the mistake in January of 2014.  Senior Deputy District Attorney Rich Orman was alerted to the mistake and filed a motion to send Lima-Marin back to prison, according to the report

On January 7, after Lima-Marin had been out for nearly six years, officers came to his door to take him back to prison.

Lima-Marin’s wife Jasmine said that day was the worst day of her life and that “it hasn’t gotten any better since then.”

ABC News reported that Lima-Marin filed an appeal in 2000 but less than one year later asked for it to be dismissed. Prosecutors said they believe this shows that he knew about the error, and didn’t want it to be discovered.

Orman said he believes Lima-Marin should not get off just because of a clerical error.

“He should go back because the law requires the sentence he received. This was a number of very serious criminal offenses, and anything less would be inappropriate,” Orman said.

Jasmine, however, said she does not think her husband knew, because he would have told her.

“That was his life, raising his kids and being a husband,” Jasmine said, according to ABC News. “He definitely was not the same person that he was when he went in to prison.”

In April Lima-Marin’s public defender requested he be released, but the request was denied.

The family is reportedly considering another appeal.


  • balthcat

    Well someone did. Are you pretending to be obtuse and suggesting they stole him, or are you being pedantic about him “giving birth” despite the fact it’s common now to speak of such things as a partnership achievement?

  • Taren Goulet-Long

    Cornealious Michael Anderson III. I thought this story sounded a bit familiar. Here is another story: Man was convicted of robbery and sentenced to 13 years. A clerical error got him released after only 2 years. He spends the next 11 years getting his life together, starting a business, and keeping his nose clean. Not so much as a speeding ticket. It comes time for his sentence to expire and they realize that he hasn’t served it. US Marshals kick down his door and haul him, forcing him to leave his 2-year-old with his mother-in-law. That was July 25th 2013, on May 5th 2014 he was released after his attorney filed numerous appeals and petitions,
    Main Differences: 13 years vs 98 years; and in Anderson’s case the victim didn’t think he should be in jail either.
    The main point: This appears to be happening with an alarming regularity, and the justice system is lax to recognize their mistakes. Ultimately, this should go as cruel and unusual punishment, in my opinion, because you shouldn’t be able to that to a family. That being said, the severity of the crime and the sentence need to be held in balance. Either way, the justice system obviously needs oversight management.

Comments are closed.