U.S. Navy commander in hunt for airline ‘optimistic’ as search area narrows

Missing Malaysian plane: Could it have landed?

(CNN) — The U.S. Navy commander leading the American effort to find Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 said he’s “optimistic” about how the search is proceeding.

“We are detecting very continuous pings coming through in a manner consistent with exactly what you’d expect from a black box,” Cmdr. William Marks told CNN’s Erin Burnett on Friday. “We’ve ruled out that it was anything natural, or anything from commercial shipping, or anything like that.”

Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott said earlier Friday that search efforts are heading in the right direction. Marks said, “I agree with the prime minister. We’re optimistic.”

Up to nine military aircraft, one civil aircraft and 14 ships will assist in Saturday’s search for the airliner, Australia’s Joint Agency Coordination Centre said in a press release. The center of the 41,393-square-kilometer (16,000 square-mile) search area lies about 2,331 kilometers (1,448 miles) northwest of Perth.

During a visit to China, Abbott said, “We have very much narrowed down the search area, and we are very confident that the signals that we are detecting are from the black box.”

Abbott was referring to the plane’s flight data recorder and the cockpit voice recorder. Locator beacons attached to them are designed to emit high-pitched signals, or pings.

Over the past week, four such pings have been detected by a ping locator towed by the Australian vessel Ocean Shield.

“We are confident that we know the position of the black box flight recorder to within some kilometers, but confidence in the approximate position of the black box is not the same as recovering wreckage from almost 4½ kilometers beneath the sea or finally determining all that happened on that flight,” he said.

A fifth ping, detected Thursday by a sonobuoy dropped by an airplane, is “unlikely to be related to the aircraft black boxes,” Australian chief search coordinator Angus Houston said Friday.

“On the information I have available to me, there has been no major breakthrough in the search for MH370,” Houston said in a statement Friday. “Further analysis continues to be undertaken by Australian Joint Acoustic Analysis Centre.”

Friday was Day 35 in the search, and the batteries powering the flight data recorders’ locator beacons are certified to emit signals for only 30 days after they get wet.

That has injected the search effort with a heightened sense of urgency.

The signal is “starting to fade, and we are hoping to get as much information as we can before the signal finally expires,” Abbott said.

Families skeptical

Families of the 239 people who were aboard when the plane disappeared from radar screens early March 8 met Friday with Malaysia Airlines and government officials. They came away unpersuaded that progress was being made.

“Today, all they said was that they were confident,” family representative Steve Wang said. “But that really doesn’t mean that they have confirmed it. They didn’t use the word ‘confirm.’ So it could be that it’s a real lead, but it could also not be. I think that, at the moment, everyone needs to wait for final, confirmed information.”

That view was echoed by Sarah Bajc, whose partner, Philip Wood, was among the passengers.

“Every time some official gives one of those absolute statements of ‘We’re sure it’s the pings from the black boxes’ or ‘We’re sure it’s in the ocean,’ we all crash,” she told CNN’s “New Day.”

“Our feet get knocked out from underneath us. But then it always ends up reversing itself, and they step back from it.”

She expressed skepticism about the way the investigation has been handled. “The fox is very much in charge of the henhouse here,” she told “New Day.” “We’ve got a country leading the investigation who also has the primary liability in the case, and it makes us question every step that’s taken.”

More clues

A senior Malaysian government official and another source involved in the investigation divulged new details about the flight to CNN on Thursday, including information about what radar detected, the last words from the cockpit and how high the plane was flying after it went off the grid.

Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 disappeared from military radar for about 120 nautical miles after it crossed back over the Malay Peninsula, sources said. Based on available data, this means the plane must have dipped in altitude to between 4,000 and 5,000 feet, sources said.

The dip could have been programmed into the computers controlling the plane as an emergency maneuver, said aviation expert David Soucie.

“The real issue here is it looks like — more and more — somebody in the cockpit was directing this plane and directing it away from land,” said Peter Goelz, a CNN aviation analyst and former National Transportation Safety Board managing director.

“And it looks as though they were doing it to avoid any kind of detection.”

But former U.S. Department of Transportation Inspector General Mary Schiavo was not convinced. She said the reported dip could have occurred in response to a loss of pressure, to reach a level where pressurization was not needed and those aboard the plane would have been able to breathe without oxygen, or to get out of the way of commercial traffic, which typically flies at higher altitudes.

That would have been necessary had the plane’s transponder been turned off and it lost communications.

“If you don’t have any communications, you need to get out of other traffic,” Schiavo said.

“We still don’t have any motive and any evidence of a crime yet,” she said, adding that most radar can track planes at altitudes below 4,000 feet, so the plane’s descent may not have indicated any attempt by whoever was controlling it to hide.

She held out hope that the black boxes hold the answers and that they will be found soon.

New flight details revealed

Malaysian sources told CNN that Flight 370’s pilot, Capt. Zaharie Ahmad Shah, was the last person on the jet to speak to air traffic controllers, telling them “Good night, Malaysian three-seven-zero.”

The sources said there was nothing unusual about his voice, which conveyed no indication that he was under stress.

One of the sources, an official involved in the investigation, told CNN that police played the recording to five other Malaysia Airlines pilots who knew the pilot and co-pilot.

“There were no third-party voices,” the source said.

Search area shrinks

Up to 12 military aircraft, three civil aircraft and 13 ships were assigned to assist in Friday’s search for the Boeing 777-200ER, which was carrying 239 people when it vanished on March 8 on a fight from Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, to Beijing.

There were no sightings reported by search aircraft or objects recovered by ships Thursday, the Joint Agency Coordination Centre said.

Friday’s search area was about 18,000 square miles (46,600 square kilometers), centered 1,436 miles (2,311 kilometers) northwest of Perth.

That’s far smaller than the search area’s size a few weeks ago.

“It’s pretty incredible if you look at where we started, which was virtually the entire Indian Ocean. Now getting it down to what’s essentially a couple hundred square miles (where the pings have been detected) is pretty miraculous,” Marks said.

The Ocean Shield first picked up two sets of underwater pulses Saturday that were of a frequency close to that used by the locator beacons. It heard nothing more until Tuesday, when it reacquired the signals twice. The four signals were within 17 miles of one another.

As the search continues, a U.S. Navy ship will help provide supplies and fuel to the ships that are looking for the missing plane.

The USNS Cesar Chavez will help supply Australian naval ships involved in the search “in the coming days,” the Navy said in a statement.

That’s probably a sign that search teams are preparing for a lengthy hunt, analysts said.

Tracking pings is only one early step in the hunt to find the plane’s data records, wreckage and the people aboard.

“I think they’re getting ready for the long haul,” said Goelz, the aviation analyst. “Even if they do get four or five more pings, once they drop the side-scanning sonar device down, that is going to be painstaking and long. So I think they are settling in for the long search.”

CNN’s Catherine E. Shoichet, Michael Holmes, Ben Brumfield, Barbara Starr, Aaron Cooper, Rene Marsh, Will Ripley, David Molko and Elizabeth Joseph and journalists Ivy Sam and Chan Kok Leong contributed to this report.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 885 other followers