Police shoot and kill victim they mistook as kidnapping suspect

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

(HLNtv.com) — An aspiring TV producer was shot and killed Monday by deputies of the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department in a deadly case of mistaken identity, authorities announced Thursday.

John Winkler, 30, was in an apartment in West Hollywood where authorities say he and two other men were held captive at knifepoint.

“Deputies were told by informants there were only two males residing in the apartment and described the suspect as a male, white, thin build, wearing a black shirt,” a Sheriff’s Department news release states.

Entry team members outside the apartment announced themselves but received no response. That’s when the apartment door suddenly opened and a male rushed out, police said.

“He was covered in blood and bleeding profusely from the neck,” according to the news release.

At the same time, deputies said, Winkler ran out of the door and lunged at the back of the fleeing victim. Authorities said both of the victims ran directly at the deputies.

Winkler was wearing a black shirt similar to what the suspect was described as wearing, authorities said.

“Believing Winkler was the assailant and the assault was ongoing and he would attack the entry team; three deputies fired their duty weapons at him,” the news release states. Both men were hit by gunfire.

Winkler was taken to a local hospital, where he died from a single gunshot wound. According to the Los Angeles Times, Winkler was a production assistant for the Comedy Central show, “Tosh.0.” CNN has reached out to “Tosh.0,” but the show has not commented at this time.

Once deputies entered the apartment, they said they saw another male victim lying on the living room floor fighting with the suspect, now identified as Alexander McDonald, 27.

McDonald had overpowered the victim and was choking him and tearing at his face, police said.

“Deputies could see the victim was about to go unconscious and a large knife was on the floor near them. The deputies were able to use physical force to subdue the suspect and end the assault,” the release said.

Authorities said they learned that the suspect, in a rage, began stabbing the men and fighting with them once deputies arrived.

One of the victims was a roommate of McDonald, according to deputies. Winkler and the other victim were visiting at the time of the incident, deputies said.

The second victim who ran outside of the apartment just before Winkler was shot was treated for stab wounds to the neck and a gunshot wound to the leg. He is in stable condition.

The third victim was treated for stab wounds to the legs, arms and chest. He has been released from a hospital.

McDonald was treated for minor injuries and released from a hospital. He is in custody, charged with one count of murder, two counts of attempted murder and one count of torture. His bail has been set at $4 million.

“I have no doubt the entire Sheriff’s Department mourns the death of John Winkler, none more than the deputies involved,” Los Angeles County Sheriff John Scott said at a news conference Thursday.


  • theSharperTool

    I’m glad you’re not a cop there, cowboy. Please never touch a firearm, saying things like “why did they shoot to kill”. They shoot center mass because it ensures that bystanders don’t get killed from pass-through shots, and to ensure the bullet dissipates energy, and doesn’t open up two wound channels, causing faster, uncontrollable bleedout. A shot to the arm would leave twice the holes to bleed from, and likely rupture the brachial artery, causing death within five minutes.

    And had you ever handled a firearm in any high-stress situation, you’d know that it’s really hard to identify someone’s intent when they’re chasing after someone with blood pouring from their neck; let alone when you’ve been told that the person who caused that bloodletting looks like that person, and they’re not stopping when you’re screaming for them to stop.

    • Bryan C

      Police officers are trained for these situations. They shot an unarmed man who was, as the story told, was bleeding from the neck. I am sure it was intense. Do I think they did this on purpose? No. Do I think more constraint could of been used? Yes. It sounds like the suspect get charged with a murder he actually did not commit though.

  • Buzzman

    First of all, we don’t know WHAT happened, do we. All we have is the LAPD’s side of the story.However, with no guns in sight, it seems a para military trained officer could have taken down a victim before opening up numerous rounds of deadly force.

Comments are closed.