Manufacturer says Flight 370 black boxes missed overhaul set for 2012
WASHINGTON (CNN) — The acoustic pingers believed to be on Malaysia Airline Flight 370’s two black boxes were due for overhauls and battery replacements in 2012 but were never returned to their manufacturer, the manufacturer tells CNN.
The revelation leaves three possibilities, said Anish Patel, president of pinger manufacturer Dukane Seacom of Sarasota, Florida: The airline could have replaced the old pingers with new ones, it could have had another company perform the necessary maintenance, or it could have let the scheduled maintenance lapse, meaning the pingers would have a shortened battery life.
If the original batteries remain in the pingers, the battery life probably will have dropped from the required 30 days to 20 or 25 days, Patel says.
Malaysia Airlines did not respond Thursday to a question from CNN about whether the pingers on Flight 370 are compliant. But in an earlier e-mail last week about the airline’s storage practices, Malaysia Airlines said, “We are unaware of any issue with the ULB (pinger) or its batteries.”
“This battery is not replaceable,” the airline said. “The battery is built-in inside the (pinger) and installed by OEM — Original Equipment Manufacturer.”
Patel said the National Transportation Safety Board has told his company that it manufactured the pingers on Flight 370’s black boxes, formally known as the flight data recorder and the cockpit voice recorder.
The devices were manufactured in late 2005 and late 2006 and were due for overhauls and new batteries in 2012, Patel said.
But “we have no record of those units ever coming back for a battery replacement,” he said.
The lithium batteries are enclosed in the pinger, a watertight container roughly the size of a roll of silver dollars. Because pingers are sealed, airlines typically return them to the manufacturer for battery replacement, Patel said. But airlines sometime choose to have other companies do the work, or they replace the pingers entirely, he said.
Patel said Malaysia Airlines used to send pingers to Dukane Seacom, a division of Radiant Power Corp. of Sarasota, Florida, for maintenance but has not in the “last couple years.”
“Up until 2009, 2010, we used to see it on a regular basis. So they could have gone to another protocol such as doing it themselves, or they could have gone to another repair facility.”
Or it could have let the maintenance lapse, he said.
“Theoretically, they could have 8-year-old batteries,” Patel said.
Pingers are required to operate for a minimum of 30 days. To ensure that requirement, manufacturers install batteries that can last several days longer. Patel predicted that his pingers could work for 33 to 35 days, or perhaps longer, at full strength.
But that time span would decrease if the batteries were not replaced, he said.
The pinger sound, which is inaudible to human ears, does not stop immediately after it surpasses its full-strength design life, but fades over time.
The pinger will continue to emit signals with “progressively lower output levels until the unit shuts down,” Patel said.
Honeywell, the aerospace company that manufactured the black boxes on Flight 370, confirmed that the Dukane Seacom pingers were installed on the recorders at the time of manufacture, and remained on the boxes during maintenance checks in 2006 and 2007.
In 2006, the airline sent the cockpit voice recorder to Honeywell for an overhaul and modifications, Honeywell spokesman Steven Brecken said. The company noted in its paperwork that the pinger, also called a locator beacon, was set to expire in 2012, he said.
In 2007, the airline sent the flight data recorder to Honeywell after a cockpit light indicated there was a fault with the device. “We performed a check on it and didn’t find any type of faults.” Honeywell “made sure it was working 100 percent” and returned the recorder to the airline, Brecken said. The company noted in its paperwork that the beacon was set to expire in 2012, he said.
Honeywell has no record indicating whether the airline serviced the beacons as scheduled.
“We don’t perform the maintenance on the beacons; that’s up to the airlines,” Brecken said.
Dukane Seacom pingers have played a role in several aviation investigations, including TWA 800, Swiss Air 111 and Air France 447. In the Air France crash, a pinger detector was unable to find the pinger, and it took two years for searchers to find the wreckage. In that case, investigators recovered one pinger and attempted to test it to determine if it had malfunctioned. But the pinger was too corroded and the tests were inconclusive, Patel said.